Wooden letter cube with a section sign

Compliance

Email archiving is a duty, not an option

For many companies, email archiving is not high on the list of priorities. Then a tax audit, a legal dispute or a cyber attack raises the question of audit-proof archiving. Yet in Germany, email archiving is not an option. It is a legal duty.

Anyone who does not archive business emails in line with GoBD risks tax disadvantages, fines and damage to their reputation. At the same time, NIS2, DORA and other EU regulations keep raising the requirements for IT security, traceability and data integrity.

The legal duty to archive email under AO and HGB

The statutory retention periods are clearly set out, in particular in § 147 of the Fiscal Code (Abgabenordnung, AO) and § 257 of the Commercial Code (Handelsgesetzbuch, HGB):

  • 10 years: commercial books, inventories, annual financial statements, management reports, opening balance sheets and more
  • 8 years: accounting records, invoices
  • 6 years: commercial and business letters

Do you have to retain emails?

Yes. Under the GoBD (principles for the proper keeping and retention of books, records and documents in electronic form), these periods expressly apply to electronic communication too. Business emails count as commercial or business letters under AO and HGB, so they fall under the statutory archiving duty.

What GoBD-compliant email archiving requires

Filing emails in a mailbox or using a backup solution does not usually meet these requirements. Without an audit-proof email archive, you face considerable tax risks in a tax audit.

Regulatory requirements go far beyond GoBD

Email archiving matters for more than tax. Depending on your industry and the size of your company, many further regulatory requirements apply. For managing directors and IT managers, archiving is therefore part of the company-wide compliance strategy and not just an IT matter.

NIS2 and email archiving as part of your cybersecurity strategy

The NIS2 Directive tightens cybersecurity requirements for companies in 18 sectors. It covers so-called “essential” and “important” entities, including energy, health, transport, finance and IT service providers.

Among other things, it calls for risk management measures, access controls, encryption, logging and business continuity plans. An audit-proof email archive supports these requirements through:

  • encrypted storage,
  • tamper-proof logging,
  • controlled permissions,
  • and redundant data storage.

This makes archiving an important part of your company’s cyber resilience.

DORA for digital resilience in the financial sector

The Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA) obliges financial entities and critical ICT service providers to manage digital risks in a structured way. Its core requirements include ICT risk management, data integrity and traceability, business continuity strategies, incident management and third-party risk assessment. Audit-proof email archiving supports data integrity, traceability and availability in particular.

Does Microsoft 365 meet the statutory archiving duties?

Many companies assume that Microsoft 365 archives in line with GoBD automatically. That is a common mistake.

Key points

  • Exchange Online archiving is only included in certain plans.
  • Microsoft secures the availability of the service, not audit-proof retention in the sense of tax law.
  • Emails can be deleted by user actions or attacks.
  • Archiving takes place within the Microsoft ecosystem.

Another point that matters to many companies is that US providers can, under certain conditions, be required to hand over data under the CLOUD Act, regardless of where the data is stored. For companies with high compliance requirements, this raises the question of digital sovereignty.

EMA – legally compliant email archiving Made in Germany

EMA, the archive from ARTEC IT Solutions, offers:

  • automatic, audit-proof archiving,
  • digital signatures and timestamps,
  • highly secure encrypted storage,
  • platform-independent integration (e.g. Microsoft 365, Exchange on-premises),
  • fast full-text search,
  • 100% development and hosting in Germany.

No per-user licensing model: Instead of costs that rise with every new employee, companies pay a monthly flat rate, with no mailbox, user or size limits. Firmware updates and new features are included, with no extra cost and no complex migration projects.

Besides emails, you can also archive documents, scans and other data sources. That turns a legal duty into a productive working tool.

When should companies act?

Typical triggers for introducing professional email archiving are tax audits, migrating to Microsoft 365, a ransomware incident, being affected by NIS2 or DORA, or a sharp rise in email volume.

Strategically, though, it makes sense to introduce archiving before a risk materialises.

ARTEC – 30 years of experience in archiving and data management Made in Germany

ARTEC IT Solutions has developed and run EMA for 30 years as an owner-managed company in Germany.

This content is for general information only. It does not constitute legal advice and does not replace it. All information is provided without guarantee.